The Ultimate Seafood Lover's Guide to Sarasota
Where to find the best fresh seafood in Sarasota, Florida—and the signature saltwater dishes to order at each.
With over 35 miles of coastline, it’s no surprise that Sarasota is home to some of the finest seafood restaurants in the Sunshine State.
From upscale anchor-and-eat restaurants to casual beachside bars and local fish markets, Sarasota's seafood scene flows far and wide like our Gulf waters. Succulent pink shrimp, tender grouper sandwiches, Florida-famous stone crab, spear-caught hogfish, spiny lobster tail, freshly shucked oysters—you name it. Our tide-to-table guide to Sarasota area's seafood restaurants will keep you baited, hooked and coming back for more.
Siesta Key Seafood
Captain Curt's Crab & Oyster Bar: A traditional Old Florida seafood house on the south end of Siesta Key, Captain Curt's landmark tiki bar is known for its island vibe and famous bowl of award-winning clam chowder. Dive into wild-caught seafood fare like Gulf Grouper, Sea Scallops or signature Hogfish Dinner, paired with a cold draft beer and live music for a true taste of coastal living in Siesta Key.
Siesta Key Oyster Bar (SKOB): Known for its ultra laid-back atmosphere and lively beach vibe, SKOB is a favorite group hangout for locals and drifters alike. Expect daily live music and a fun scene in the heart of Siesta Village. Feast on a variety of dive-bar and seafood classics like Jumbo Peel-N-Eat Shrimp, Lump Crab Hushpuppies, Chef's Daily Fish Dip and, of course, fresh oysters on the half shell (half-price during happy hour). Pair with a round of Florida brews after a day of salt and sun.

Cafe Gabbiano, Siesta Key
Cafe Gabbiano: Located steps from the Village, Café Gabbiano brings an elegant, wine-centric touch to coastal dining. While known for its romantic private wine rooms and authentic Italian heritage, the menu highlights exquisite seafood dishes—from squid ink pasta tossed with fresh Gulf shrimp and sea scallops to pan-seared grouper over saffron risotto and classic frutti di mare.
Spearfish Grille: Tucked under the South Siesta Bridge, Spearfish offers a delightful all-outdoor dining experience under its tiki roof with fresh "caught-that-day" creations and views of the neighboring boatyard. Don't worry if there's a wait—staff is usually posted just outside, grilling up oysters and serving bottles of beer to those waiting for a table. Once seated, indulge in shared apps like Conch Fritters, Crispy Fried Grouper Cheeks or Ahi Tuna Nachos.
Big Water Fish Market: This no-frills locals' spot offers a great selection of fresh, wild-caught Florida and non-Florida fish—blackened or grilled and expertly prepared, along with prepared sides. Offerings change daily, depending on what’s being caught, so one day you might find hogfish, wahoo or tripletail, and the next day, something else.
Lido Key & Longboat Key Seafood
Crab & Fin, Lido Key
Crab & Fin Restaurant: Situated right on St. Armands Circle, Crab & Fin offers upscale indoor and alfresco dining with a focus on tide-to-table menu items. Indulge in Fresh Catch Selections like Whole Local Mangrove Snapper, Mediterranean Bronzini, Low Country Bouillabaisse, Caribbean Yellowfin Tuna and more fin-fresh standouts, complemented by an extensive wine list and white-tablecloth service in a refined yet relaxed sidewalk setting.
Chart House: Perched at the entrance of Longboat Key, Chart House offers upscale waterfront dining with breathtaking views of the Gulf waters of Sarasota Bay. Enjoy a menu of high-end seafood favorites like the Macadamia Crusted Mahi, Black Ink Linguine Di Mare or the Wild-caught King Crab, or venture down the "Dock To Dine" section of the menu. All entrees are paired with attentive service in an elegant setting. Happy hour specials from the bar seating are a great way to unwind after an all-day outing on the boat.
Dry Dock Waterfront Grill: This beloved eatery sits on the bay side of Longboat Key with boat-up access. Dry Dock is renowned for its casual dockside ambiance and delicious seafood dishes. From the award-winning Grouper Sandwich and Boathouse Tacos to Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes and the Chilean Sea Bass, every dish is prepared with the freshest ingredients and served with a side of waterfront charm.
The Lazy Lobster: Nestled on the mid-island stretch of Longboat, Lazy Lobster offers a charming, neighborhood feel with a focus on high-quality, approachable seafood. The kitchen specializes in everything lobster—from rich lobster bisque and lobster tacos to a mac & cheese and whole steamed tails—alongside local catches like pecan-crusted grouper and seared sea scallops, all served in a bright, tropical setting.
Sarasota Seafood

Duval's Fresh Local Seafood, Downtown Sarasota
Duval's Fresh Local Seafood: Located in the heart of Downtown Sarasota, Duval's is a culinary hotspot known for innovative seafood creations made with the highest-quality ingredients from local fishermen and farmers. Feast on appetizers like Siesta Key Calamari, Seafood Bruschetta and Coconut Curry Mussels before diving into dishes like the Scallops Rockefeller, Ocean Scampi and Lobster Mac & Cheese. Pair with a glass of fine wine while people-watching passersby on Main Street.
Captain Brian's Seafood Market & Restaurant: Located in North Sarasota, Captain Brian's is a seafood market and Zagat-rated restaurant off the beaten path. A must-have to kick off your meal is Chef Brian's famous fish dip (smoked on-site). Choose from a daily selection of locally sourced seafood and have it prepared to your liking, whether grilled, blackened or fried. Then shop around to take home Florida Stone Crab Claws or fish fillets from the market.

Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar, Downtown Sarasota
Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar: Situated in downtown's Rosemary District, Lefty's is known for its airy beer-garden seating, weekend live music and happy hours. The menu centers around fresh, local seafood—highlighted by an extensive raw bar of seasonal oysters freshly shucked on the half shell, snow crab (when it's in season), Drunken Clams and Mussels Frites. Fried specialties include Key West Conch Fritters, Fried Soft Shell Crabs, Gulf Grouper and Gator Bites.
Tripletail Seafood & Spirits: Down U.S. 41, find a strip mall hidden gem in The Landings. Tripletail Seafood & Spirits offers coastal-inspired cuisine and innovative craft cocktails, plus a fantastic daily happy hour that includes fish cakes and Tuna Tartare. Otherwise, indulge in a vast selection of seafood dishes, from Coconut Shrimp Salad and Smoked Bourbon Oysters to their signature Tripletail fish, seasoned and sautéed to perfection.
Kacey's Seafood & More: With two locations in Sarasota, Kacey's offers double the dining experience with a focus on affordable seafood and family-friendly service. Find crispy-gold favorites like the Fried Shrimp Basket, Fried Clam Strips and some of the best Fish & Chips in the area, served with classic sides and homemade sauces for a satisfying meal.
Englewood Seafood

Farlow's on the Water, Englewood
Farlow's On The Water: Situated on the shoreline of Ainger Creek in Englewood, Farlow's offers a picturesque setting with a southern twist on saltwater varieties. Enjoy Caribbean-inspired dishes like the St. Croix Crab Cake, Anguilla Hog Fish, Barbados Mussels, Southern Style Triggerfish and the house specialty, Martinique Cobia, paired with island vibes and southern hospitality for a memorable dining experience.
Landy's Restaurant: A local favorite just a few minutes from Englewood Beach, Landy's is known for its classic seafood dishes and family-owned charm. Taste unique appetizers on the beautiful garden patio overlooking the water, like the Dynamite Shrimp, Seafood Lemon Drop or Turf N Surf Board. Entrées from the sea include the Catch of the Day, Manasota Mahi, Orange Crusted Grouper and the Seafood Platter, served with a side of Southern hospitality and Old Florida nostalgia.
Nokomis & Venice Seafood
Crow's Nest Marina Restaurant, Venice
Crow's Nest Marina Restaurant: Overlooking the marina in Venice, Crow's Nest offers fine dining with a relaxed waterfront ambiance. With wine in hand, toast to Raw Bar options for your first course, like Gulf Oysters, Top Neck Clams, Classic Shrimp Cocktail and the Seafood Tower. Or skip right to the main course to fill up on the Deep Fried Captain's Platter, Open-Faced Seafood Ravioli or Walnut Crusted Salmon, accompanied by panoramic views and impeccable service for a true ocean-to-table dining experience.
Dockside Waterfront Grill: Located at Venice's historic Fisherman's Wharf Marina, Dockside offers scenes of passing boats, dolphins and harbor sunsets. Accessible by land or sea, this breezy tiki-style venue serves up daily happy hour and Florida-focused seafood dishes. Feast on Snack & Share items like the Crab Mango Stack or Lobster Lollipops, then enjoy a bowl of Fishcamp Chowder. Finish strong with a Lobster Roll or Boom Boom Grouper Wrap while sipping on a frozen daiquiri.

Fins at Sharky's, Venice
Fins at Sharky's: At the entrance of the Venice Beach Fishing Pier, Fins at Sharky's offers a refined dining atmosphere with an unparalleled view of Venice Beach and a focus on American coastal cuisine. Go for char-grilled specialties like the Spanish Octopus, Faroe Island Salmon or Pacific Mahi Mahi. Top it all off with an island-style craft cocktail and enjoy front-row seats to the daily sunset show.
Pop's Sunset Grill: Situated on the Nokomis waterfront (just north of Venice), Pop's Sunset Grill offers stunning inlet views and a laid-back, tropical tiki bar setting. Boaters and diners alike can dock and dine on comfort dishes like the Beer Battered Fish Platter, Coconut Shrimp Platter, Famous Grouper Reuben or Marker 10 Fish Tacos, while soaking in the sunset and enjoying live music on the outdoor deck.
Lakewood Ranch Seafood
Lucky Pelican Bistro: This local gem is hidden in a Lakewood Ranch strip mall and worth the trip to find. Lucky Pelican features a lively open kitchen and a daily chalked menu of fresh catches with a down-home vibe. Enjoy Florida brews with sharables like peel-and-eat Gulf shrimp, smoked fish spread and buffalo fried calamari, then move to main-hitter handhelds, like the Ocean Burrito, Fried Oyster Po Boy and Scallop Sliders.

Deep Lagoon, Waterside Place
Deep Lagoon Seafood & Oyster House: Located in Waterside Place, Deep Lagoon combines scenic lake views with a polished sea-to-table dining concept. Guests can enjoy a warm breeze, live music and an impressive raw bar. Seafood appetizer highlights include Thai Chili Calamari, Crab Rangoon and Tuna Tataki, while the "Big Chill" and "Little Chill" Seafood Towers are another way to get the party started. For another waterfront location, check out the original Deep Lagoon restaurant in Osprey. Both locations offer a market counter where you can take home your favorites on ice.
Anna Maria Oyster Bar: Located in the heart of the University Town Center, this outpost is actually one of many throughout the county. This beloved local chain brings a fun, family-friendly and laid-back vibe to the mainland. Known for its famous "five-buck" margaritas and warm hospitality, the menu centers around fresh, affordable seafood—highlighted by raw, steamed or baked oysters, plus crispy fried clam strips, coconut shrimp and classic fish 'n' chips.
You Hook It, They Cook It
Nothing beats the reward of turning a successful day out fishing into a rewarding dining experience. Several favorite local spots will happily prepare your fresh-caught fish—as long as you bring your fillets cleaned, scaled and ready for the kitchen.
Historic staples like Walt’s Fish Market & Restaurant in Sarasota and Captain Eddie’s Seafood in Nokomis will cook your catch to order (fried, blackened or grilled), served alongside classic sides. For a more elevated harbor view, Marina Jack turns your haul into a polished waterfront dinner, or head to one of Daiquiri Deck's seaside locations (Siesta Key, Lido Key and Venice) for an island-energy post-charter meal.